Ten-man Chelsea secure Arsenal to a tie in fiery London derby.
Chelsea manager Enzo Maresca was feeling aggrieved. This frustration stemmed not from the dismissal of his midfielder against Arsenal, but over what he perceived to be a notable absence of uniform application from the match referees.
It's easy to understand his point. Last month, Tottenham midfielder Rodrigo Bentancur was booked for a challenge on Reece James, a ruling the video review system agreed with. Yet, when Caicedo was cautioned for a seemingly similar challenge on Mikel Merino, the VAR intervened to upgrade it to a straight dismissal.
"That is a sending-off offence, but why was the Uruguayan's on Reece James not a red card? We, as coaches, we struggle to understand why they judge in a different way," the manager questioned.
Analyzing the Distinction?
Well, outcomes are partly dependent upon who the VAR is—which makes true consistency very difficult.
No two fouls is ever the same, and there were nuanced distinctions between the two challenges. The Tottenham player was primarily stepping in, while the Chelsea man jumped a little and his point of contact was a bit more elevated.
There was also a pronounced buckle of the midfielder's joint, a sign a video referee watches for to indicate undue severity, and his boot was shifted on the pitch surface.
Regarding the earlier incident, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel backed the caution for Bentancur by a margin of four to one, and unanimously backed no VAR intervention "due to the reasoning that the tackle was near the ground, marginally tardy and reckless".
This same panel will undoubtedly back the call to send off Caicedo, but it won't be too long before another tackle of this nature is judged just a yellow card.
Did the VAR Tell the Referee to Show a Caution?
The Chelsea midfielder will be banned for three matches following his dismissal against the North London side.
The situation seemed somewhat perplexing at first. Was referee Anthony Taylor being advised to book Caicedo so the foul could be checked?
In reality, there's a much more straightforward reason.
Taylor played advantage for Arsenal as the loose ball was with a Gunners player. When it went out for a throw-in, the referee returned to caution Caicedo, who was receiving treatment. Officials are told to delay until an player at fault is back on their feet before displaying a disciplinary sanction.
Therefore, the pause was not because the VAR was checking; it was since the player was with the physio.
Video assistant referee John Brooks can reach the conclusion that there was sufficient severity for a red, but he has to wait for Taylor to make clear his initial decision. As soon as Taylor showed a yellow, the VAR promptly instructed him to the monitor because the assessment had been completed during the medical stoppage.
Referee Overturns Red Card Review
In another Sunday match, for just the second instance in the top flight, a match official overturned a VAR upgrade recommendation at the pitchside monitor.
The referee hadn't given a foul against the player, so in contrast to the Arsenal incident, the resumption of play was a free-kick to Aston Villa. The video assistant, Bell, felt that the manner Arias launched himself with both feet endangered the opponent's safety.
Yet, the challenger was in the air and took a risk, making contact with the upper part of Kamara's boot. It lacked the level of intensity typically required for a straight red, even if it was not a great challenge.
Was There a Case For The Blues' Goal to Be Disallowed for an Offside Offence?
The VAR determined that Enzo Fernandez did not interfere on the defenders when Chalobah scored the first goal for Chelsea.
Once again, and another series of debatable rulings on player positioning.
A possible offside on Chelsea's goal appears to have gone under the radar.
Reece James delivered a set-piece in from the left, and Chalobah guided a header into the back of the net.
However, there existed a potential issue. Enzo Fernandez was stood in an offside position and was in close proximity to defenders Piero Hincapie and Mosquera.
Did Fernandez affect the decision-making of either defender? Had the Chelsea player not been there, would there have been a greater opportunity of preventing the header?
Fernandez made no attempt to make contact with the ball, and while he was not physically contesting with one defender, he had his arm on Hincapie's back.
One could argue a very strong case for an offside call, so it returns us to a question of uniform interpretation yet again.
Did The Defender Have Seen Red for an Elbow?
Piero Hincapie was in the lineup for the Gunners with their first-choice centre-backs unavailable through fitness issues.
It was shortly after the first red card. Hincapie went up for a ball with the Chelsea player, and the Chelsea defender came off worse through contact by the elbow on his head.
"I asked the official, he told me that it was not an elbow," the Chelsea manager explained. "So, this is what they said. He had a facial injury, with an ice pack at half-time. But they decide in a different way."
Match officials should not make judgements based solely on a potential injury, though it undoubtedly happens. A footballer can sustain a cut or a contusion from many kinds of contact, so it would not be a sound basis.
As with dangerous tackles, officials have a set of criteria they assess for a potential elbow offence.
- Was it an unnatural way of challenging for a high ball?
- Was there a closed fist, which indicates aggression?
- Was the elbow thrown or lifted to create force?
None of these were present, so a yellow card was considered sufficient.